Forgive me for throwing this story of a birding adventure out onto the internets before the tale of the three 10,000 Birds bloggers getting together on Friday for the first time, which you will all get to read about soon enough, but I saw some pretty darn cool birds today and I couldn’t wait to write about them! On Friday our plans to head upstate in search of winter rarities were scotched when a winter storm made the distances we needed to travel unfeasible so I decided to see if I could find some of the birds on my own on my way back upstate to Albany from New York City today. My first goal? The Hoary Redpoll which has been frequenting feeders in the town of Montgomery in Orange County.

A Hoary Redpoll is essentially a bigger, whiter, and rarer Common Redpoll (if you want more information than that about how to tell the two apart please go see David Sibley’s excellent series of posts about redpolls). The one in Montgomery has been visiting Curt McDermott’s feeders for over fifty days now, which is fortunate because Curt is a birder and he was pretty sure he knew what he had when he saw it. Many birders have been to see the bird and Curt, by all accounts, has been a gracious host (to birders whom he welcomes and to birds, for whom he puts out over a hundred pounds of seed every three weeks!). Curt showed some marvelous birding etiquette today when I pulled up outside of his home to view the feeders in his side yard. He was outside sitting with his camera, waiting to get the perfect shot of the bird. When I arrived he decided to go inside, despite my objections, because he felt that his presence near the feeders was keeping the bird from showing. Sure enough, within ten minutes of his heading in the bird showed!

Hoary Redpoll in Montgomery, Orange County, New York

Hoary Redpoll with Common Redpoll and American Goldfinches

Not only did Curt prove himself the ultimate host of a rare bird by displacing himself from his own yard, but after the bird showed and he found out it was a lifer for me he presented me with a great picture of it, taken by one of his visitors, which he said was a necessary memento of getting a lifer. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, Birders Rule!

But after my latest addition to my life list I wasn’t done yet. On my way out of Montgomery I gave a call to Chrissy, who lives near there, to let her know I had seen the bird. She suggested a back road I could take that would lead me directly to Humpo Marsh in New Paltz where Red-headed Woodpeckers are known to be. Who am I to say no to what would be only my second look at such a wonderful bird? So I headed up the Albany Post Road to 299 and, unfortunately, dipped on the woodpeckers. Sure, I saw a gorgeous male Northern Harrier hunting the marsh and Swamp, Song, and American Tree Sparrows, to say nothing of a Northern Flicker and a Downy Woodpecker, but I was still kind of bummed as I headed back to the New York State Thruway entrance in New Paltz.

Then I spotted a flock of Canada Geese in a field and one of them didn’t look right. So I nailed the brakes, almost got rear-ended, sped back up, pulled a rather daring U-turn, and parked on the shoulder halfway in a snowbank and halfway in the road. Between cars going past showering me with slushy spray I spotted this:

Odd Goose

Canada Goose and, well, I don’t know

On the spot and without a field guide (or a very good memory for goose field marks, apparently), I decided it was a Greater White-fronted Goose, a Eurasian species that would be my first in North America. I called Chrissy with the news and she posted it onto the state listserv. Then I got home and eventually got to my not-very good pictures. Doh! Greater White-fronted Geese do not have white faces, but a white band at the base of the bill (which, you know, the name pretty much makes clear). But what is it? It’s not right for a dark-morph Snow Goose and it doesn’t look to me like other geese in the field guides…maybe a Canada X Greater White-fronted? All I know is I feel like I’m making a habit out of misidentifying birds

odd goose with Canada Geese

What might not be terribly obvious in the lousy pictures is that the bill is bright orange and it seemed to be at least as large as the larger Canada Geese (though the range was great and the birds were in different postures and at different distances).

Written by Corey
Corey is a New Yorker who lived most of his life in upstate New York but has lived in Queens since 2008. He's only been birding since 2005 but has garnered a respectable life list by birding whenever he wasn't working as a union representative or spending time with his family. He lives in Forest Hills with Daisy and Desmond Shearwater. His bird photographs have appeared on the Today Show, in Birding, Living Bird Magazine, Bird Watcher's Digest, and many other fine publications. He is also the author of the American Birding Association Field Guide to the Birds of New York.