eagle carrying a child - illustration

I’m currently reading Roger Real Drouin’s No Other Way for a future review on this site. The novel centers on a quest to find and save the Northern Stilted Curlew, an Eskimo Curlew analog with an unfortunate taste for habitats that are about to be disrupted by fracking. The political and literary implications are many, but combined with my other recent readings, it spun my thoughts off in a strange direction.

You see, I also spent some time lately recuperating from a bad cold (all the smoke everywhere does not help.) I deal with this sort of illness by lying in a hot bath drinking wine and revisiting beloved books of my youth, and this time out I chose Unexplained!, an encyclopedia of strange phenomena like UFOs, psychic powers, and cryptozoological creatures.

Some of those mysterious creatures were birds.

The most obvious place that cryptozoology and ornithology overlap is in the area of Lazarus taxa and would-be Lazarus taxa — the Ivory-billed Woodpecker, Eskimo Curlew, Pink-headed Duck, and the like — birds that no one doubts existed once, whether or not they exist today. On the other extreme you have outrageous stories like the supposed Thunderbird photograph of the America West, ambiguous winged creatures like Mothman and the Jersey Devil, and the impossible but incredibly persistent belief that (modern, extant) eagles can and will carry off small children.
eagle carrying a child - illustration
Come on — obviously Photoshopped!

What ornithology doesn’t seem to have is the strange demi-world that so haunts primatology, marine biology, and even herpetology — the loosely-linked collections of legends and field reports that seem to indicate the existence of species that are biologically plausible but officially unknown to science in the face of repeated searches — species like the Mono Grande and (until recently) the Giant Squid.

Now why should this be? Birds are less compelling to human interest than our fellow primates, in many regards, but surely they are more arresting than a big wad of tentacled whale chow. Unexplained! mentioned a strike against the Thunderbird that may be a strike against all avian tall tales, quoting Angelo Capparella who notes that any undiscovered giant bird would have to be a master of evasion to go unnoticed by the “the legions of competent birdwatchers … scanning the skies of the U.S. and Canada” often with cameras at ready. But surely that’s a strike against, at least, all North American cryptids (you can’t tell me that even Sandy Komito wouldn’t drop what he was doing and digiscope Bigfoot if it wandered in front of him) and really no strike at all against the hypothetical cryptid birds of remote underbirded areas. Yet aside from the occasional speculation about a surviving Moa, we get little love. It’s not like it’s hard to flip through books of old bird illustrations and find things we can’t quite account for, but these just don’t generate the press that a hairy ape-monster would.

Written by Carrie
Carrie Laben, after years of writing and birding in New York, moved to Montana to pursue her two great passions more effectively. She recently graduated with an MFA in Creative Nonfiction from the University of Montana in Missoula. When she is not cranking out essays and speculative fiction stories, or wandering around on mountains failing to see the birds she is looking for, she is likely to be drinking one of the many fine local microbrews or attending a potluck with something from the local farmer’s market in hand. On Mondays from 3 to 3:30 Mountain Time you can find her answering questions about birds on live chat at DaysAtDunrovin.com.