Birds can come to be strongly linked with places in the birder’s mind. And you name many worthy candidates for a bird to symbolize the West – from the magnificent Golden Eagle to the imperiled Sage Grouse to the marvelously adapted American Dipper. But for me, the bird that best sums up my experience out here thus far is the Black-billed Magpie, a cousin of the crows and jays that makes its home all the way down the rocky spine of the continent, from Alaska to New Mexico.

Like many members of the Corvid tribe, Black-billed Magpies are omnivorous, boisterous, bright, and social. They’re happy to come into town and hang out on the lawn, clean up scraps from the garbage (at much less risk of fatality than the other local clean-up crew, black bears,) and swing through the trees being lively on otherwise blah days, even in the gray of winter. In short, they are, to my mind, charismatic. They fill the role that the Monk Parakeet fills in Brooklyn (without the thorny issue of being non-native) or the Blue Jay fills at the feeders back in my ancestral home. Yet as I talk to new human acquaintances around town, mentioning magpies, the response I usually get is a strange look and a slow “Yeah, most people don’t like them.”

What, now?

Admittedly, their voices are not melodious – but neither are the parakeets’ or the jays’. They’re clad in black and white, not vivid blue or electric green – but black and white can be plenty cute, as we’ve all learned from pandas and orcas. Had this just been a matter of a couple of cranks, I would have written it off. Heck, there are people who don’t like woodpeckers, if you can imagine that. Somewhere, there is probably someone who doesn’t like hummingbirds (please don’t tell me about that person, I would like to maintain my faith in humanity.)

But again and again, as I talk to a classmate from Wyoming, a neighbor who has lived in Montana for years, the same response. No one ever admitted to me directly that they themselves didn’t like the birds, mind. It was always ‘some folks’ and then an odd look in my direction, similar to the reaction I get when I complain about the lack of delis that are open at three in the morning*.

I determined to track this matter to its egg.

Initial Googling revealed that the Black-billed Magpie, like so many interesting animals, once had a bounty on its head. Idaho was the state most often cited, and indeed their numbers are impressive: 150,000 dead magpies were known to have been turned in for cash, including a one-day contest where the winner shot 3400. Where there is this dedication to knocking down a species, you can usually find them eating what people would rather keep for themselves. And, in fact, the conventional wisdom behind the bounties will sound familiar to both American and British nature-lovers: Black-billed Magpies were said to eat the eggs of game birds and poultry. They would help themselves to crops and fruit trees. Having once served as tick birds on bison, they were accused by ranchers of opening sores on their cattle and causing infection. One helpful site on ‘magpie control’ (illustrated, hilariously enough, with a photo of a Northern Flicker) claimed that they would peck out the eyes of newborn and ill livestock.

When one is living hand-to-mouth, it’s reasonable not to want to share food with the fauna, I suppose, although even so the zeal it would take to shoot a few thousand birds in a day seems excessive. But modern mountaineers are not living as close to the edge as all that — we are equipped with the full compliment of restaurants and grocery stores, garden centers that sell netting for fruit trees, up-to-date veterinary techniques, and a more advanced ecological understanding of our animal world than dividing it into ‘game’ and ‘varmints’. Why does the stigma persist?

It seems that Black-billed Magpies also commit many of the modern, suburban bird sins. In the winter, they roost communally, forming loud congregations that get up early in the morning and spread whitewash liberally. In the summer, they defend their nests with dive-bombing vigor against outdoor cats (a sadly common species around here,) nosy children, and the like. They still enjoy a good fruit tree, and they’ve expanded their palate to appreciate a tasty dish of dog food. And sometimes it seems that their very intelligence offends. When the magpies work together to get at a food source (maybe a cute little duckling, maybe a heap of kibble) they are accused of being devious. When they swoop and mob a threat, they’re called bullies.

What can I say? Everything I read about them just makes me like them more.

*I get a craving for sandwiches, ok?

Written by Carrie
Carrie Laben, after years of writing and birding in New York, moved to Montana to pursue her two great passions more effectively. She recently graduated with an MFA in Creative Nonfiction from the University of Montana in Missoula. When she is not cranking out essays and speculative fiction stories, or wandering around on mountains failing to see the birds she is looking for, she is likely to be drinking one of the many fine local microbrews or attending a potluck with something from the local farmer’s market in hand. On Mondays from 3 to 3:30 Mountain Time you can find her answering questions about birds on live chat at